Very deserving on the front page, but...
This, in almost EVERY aspect, was amazing, if not perfect. The animation was fluent and beautiful, art, was very nice to look at. Characters, believable and you even start to get an emotional connection with them. Your pacing, suspense, and use of color and angles, along with music and sound effects, are brilliant in really freaking out your audience and making them sit up at the edge of their seats.
Although...the ending...it just, really didn't do it for me. I feel like it took all the suspense and intensity you built up and just made a joke out of all of it, which seemed like a waste...I think it should of been a little more of a creepy ending...more mysterious, not knowing what got the dog, and it ends with him in his cabin like in fetal position dying from starvation and the cold..with the sound of the mysterious beings loudly pounding on every angle of the shack. That would have been much better.
Everything was really brilliant...the ending just kind of pulled it back. BUT. Because this was so amazing, the animation, art, style, and feel...I'm not gonna take away a star for the ending, it just seems like this needs and deserves a ten out of ten. So good work, this definitely deserved the top banner of the front page and the daily first. Really good work, hope to see more!
-K